Wednesday, April 8, 2009

What is The Price for a Quality Legal Profession?

As law clerk, I was once assigned a project in a area of law in which I had no experience. I worked really hard on the project and learned a lot before finally turning it over to my supervisor. When the memo came back, it had comments written all over it about how disappointed my supervisor was with my work. I was devastated.

I tried to remember this experience recently when I wanted to strangle a new attorney. In the last week, this “Newbie” almost sent a Superior court motion to family court, forgot to forward me an intake on a new client ( The client then contacted me upset that he never heard back from me), and, more recently, the Newbie told me that, after careful research, there was no method by which a person could bring criminal charges against anyone else. It took me all of a five second Google search to find the following link about the process:

(http://www.mass.gov/courts/courtsandjudges/courts/bostonmunicipalcourt/
applicationprocedures.html)

Now, I know these guys will make mistakes –and I hope they do—The point of the mentoring program is for them to make these mistakes NOW – where it’s safe and they don’t need to worry about getting fired. Unfortunately, what this Newbie has done is ruin her credibility. Now I need to have all of her work double checked by a second attorney. As I often say, I would rather be told “I don’t know” 1000 times then to be told the wrong answer once.

If there is a second lesson to be learned, from an employer standpoint, mentoring is exhausting and cost prohibitive (PS- NEVER send your employer an email asking for directions to a court!) but, if we want to improve the quality of the legal profession, shouldn’t mentoring be mandatory?

1 comment:

  1. Yes! I am 15 years a lawyer (albeit 14 of those years were spent as a businessman) and screw up almost every time I am in court. So at 15 years I still need mentoring. My form - is I ask everyone and anyone questions. Most professionals are accommodating - but recently I actually had an attorney say to me "his profession is his service and his service is his livelihood." What an *ss! Another said "I can't give you legal advice." What the?!? Ask me - I will try to give an opinion - but if I don't know I will say so! Put the ego aside, act like a professional and help out - whether its a Newbie or an old fart like me just getting started with actual practice. You know what they say about karma!

    Ed

    ReplyDelete